Italo Calvino wrote, "A classic is a book that has never finished saying what it has to say."
On 16 November, the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea UNCLOS) turns 32 as a treaty in force, and I can't think of a better description of it. It's not an old book on a shelf. ITLOS, coastal, port, flag states and the odd consultant in an office in Majuro still question it, and it still answers back.
I'll admit to a soft spot here. Since sitting in the Rhodes Academy in 2022, surrounded by people who can cite articles from memory the way I can describe the parts of a purse seiner, I realised how much of my working life centres on a handful of UNCLOS articles. Most fisheries people never read the whole thing; we don't need to. Here in the Pacific, we spend time in Part V (the EEZ, Articles 55 to 75), then Part VII, (Articles 91, 92, and 94), flag-state jurisdiction and duties, and visit Part VII, (Section 2, Articles 116 to 120), the right to fish on the high seas, high seas provisions now and then.
The fisheries story of UNCLOS is really about who owns the fish. Before the EEZ, a distant-water fleet could sit 13 miles off a Pacific capital, and the island state had no say. Article 56 changed that. Sovereign rights over living resources out to 200 miles turned small island countries into resource owners overnight, at least on paper. It's no accident that the Nauru Agreement was signed in 1982, the same year the Convention opened for signature, or that FFA had already been set up in 1979 in anticipation. The Pacific read the draft text early and organised around it.
Paper rights still need to be made real, and that is where my other favourite article lives. Article 62(4) sets out what coastal states can require of foreign vessels fishing in their zone: licences, fees, observers, catch reporting, landing requirements and more. Almost everything I've worked on for the last 30 years, from the harmonised minimum terms and conditions to port inspections, is, in one way or another, an elaboration of that list. Article 73 then gives coastal states enforcement powers, with the important civilised limit that EEZ fisheries violations can't be punished with imprisonment unless the states concerned agree otherwise. I've been going through all of this for a recent FAO assignment on best practices for Fisheries Access Agreements.
But a classic is also defined by what it leaves unsaid, and UNCLOS leaves much unsaid. The high seas provisions in Articles 116 to 119 are thin, and Article 64 on highly migratory species essentially says "cooperate", which is a bit like telling a room full of competing fishing nations to play nicely.
The 1995 Fish Stocks Agreement had to fill that gap, and the RFMOs that followed, including the WCPFC, are its working machinery. The Port State Measures Agreement did the same for ports. Each new instrument is a footnote the Convention didn't have room for.
And yet, for all the legal elegance, "flag state responsibility" remains the biggest oxymoron in the fisheries world. We don't have to look any further than high seas transhipment in the WCPFC. The rules allow it only where transshipping in port is impracticable, and the flag state decides when that is the case. In practice, this works like letting students mark their own exams.
In our paper for TCC22 with Starboard and MIMRA, we tested that claim against distance to port for 1,277 transhipment events by six carriers, and a large share of them simply don't stand up, with no improvement over six years. Many of the carriers are also linked through ownership to the fishing vessels they serve.
On paper, the duty sits with the flag state, while the benefit stays with the fleet and the cost of oversight falls on the coastal states whose fish are being moved out of sight. Article 94 says the flag state shall effectively exercise its jurisdiction. Thirty-two years on, "shall" is still doing a lot of heavy lifting.
What has struck me in the last decade is how the Convention keeps saying new things through the courts. The 2015 ITLOS advisory opinion requested by the SRFC took the bare flag state duties in Article 94 and read into them a due diligence obligation to prevent IUU fishing by vessels flying the flag. That gave legal weight to something we in MCS had been saying for years. Then in 2024 ITLOS told us that greenhouse gas emissions are marine pollution under Part XII, and the ICJ followed with its own climate opinion in 2025.
So it was interesting that the aforementioned FAO contract to think about how coastal states might use their Article 62(4) powers to attach environmental and even energy efficiency conditions to access agreements. Ten years ago that would have sounded like a stretch. Today it reads as a plausible interpretation of a 1982 text.
And then there are the silences that still hurt. UNCLOS says almost nothing about the people on the boats. The word "crew" appears; the phrase "human rights" does not. Much of the work on human rights at sea, including the chapter I contributed to the Oxford Handbook, involves building that bridge from outside the Convention. Whether the gaps get filled through interpretation or new agreements is a conversation the Convention is still having.
There's also an equity question that I wrote about earlier. The text gave rights to small states, but rights without capacity tend to end up exercised by consultants on behalf of governments, which isn't quite what the drafters had in mind. I'm part of that problem, and I know it.
So, happy 32nd. Not bad for a book that took nine years to write and twelve more to take effect.
It still hasn't finished saying what it has to say, and those of us who work under it are still learning to listen.